Joanna Russ, 1937-2011
Joanna Russ, a feminist critic and science fiction writer, died on April 29. I have been meaning since then to write about her, and I find myself completely inadequate to the task. I never read her novels; all I ever read of hers was a single short story, and two nonfiction books. But if that were all that Russ had ever written, it would have been enough.
Last year I wrote a guest post at the Story Siren about reading Russ’s story “When It Changed” for the first time. I was fourteen; I had just finished my geometry final exam. It must have been almost exactly fourteen years ago. Almost exactly half my life. I think it must have been the first fiction I ever read that had a gay main character.
I am so thrilled that the Stonewall award has been established to acknowledge YA fiction that deals with LGBT experience. But it gave me a moment of pause when I heard the committee head’s words: “The ones who are perhaps going to identify as LGBTQ persons are comforted by reading about people who are like they are. Friends of GLBT, especially teenagers, are comforted by this, they learn a lot.”
Comforted. An interesting choice of words. “When It Changed” did not comfort me. It made the hairs on the back of my neck stand on end. It was more like a hurricane or a wildfire that clears out all the dead brush and, doing so, opens up patches for new things to begin growing. I didn’t read YA fiction then. I didn’t want to be told that things were going to be okay, and I didn’t want to be told to resign myself to things not being okay. What I wanted to be told — though I didn’t know it — was that things were not okay, and therefore, fight like hell.
In college I read How to Suppress Women’s Writing, a polemic on all the ways that women’s writing has historically been devalued and discounted — and continues to be. There are still people who believe that Truman Capote wrote To Kill a Mockingbird. There are still people who speak derisively of chick lit, as if everything women think about is less serious. More than any of my professors, it was Russ who made me think critically about what criteria we use when we say that this is good and that is bad; this deserves to be taken seriously and that is just fluff. It made me aware of just how much bias can be perpetuated without intent, with just going along with the way things always have been.
In To Write Like a Woman, Russ writes, “I think from now on I will not trust anyone who isn’t angry.” I read that and I thought of myself at fourteen, angry at the world and with no idea what to do with my anger. I thought of how passionately I wanted to live in a bigger world than the one I lived in. How freeing it was to be told that I wasn’t wrong for that, that it wasn’t for me to do a better job fitting into the boxes of my school; it was for me, perhaps, to do a worse job.
And not stop fighting.
Thank you, Joanna Russ



This is what a revision looks like.